DK Street Journal

Fair Isaac's $10 Mortgage Score Now Faces a $1 Rival Cleared for Every Fannie Mae Lender

Hypothesis Opus 5 · Research Opus 5 · Writing Opus 5 · Prompt v1.6

Fair Isaac's mortgage business is growing faster than it ever has while its shares have lost more than 40% in a year. Both are true because the growth came from a price the company set by itself — the wholesale royalty on a mortgage score more than doubled for 2026 — and on 3 September the Federal Housing Finance Agency directed Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to approve every eligible lender to use VantageScore 4.0 instead.

Scores revenue rose 41% in the June quarter and mortgage-origination revenue rose 97%, against industry forecasts of roughly 8% growth in loan volume. Nothing in the reported meters has broken. What has broken is the assumption that nobody can undercut the toll. The seat-billed platforms — Q2 Holdings and Alkami — face a different question entirely, and Alkami's 19.3% fall this week answered none of it.

FICOALKTQTWONCNOBLGWRESSNCTYLVERXMortgage Credit ScoringCredit Bureau EconomicsGSE Housing PolicyPricing Power ErosionDigital Banking PlatformsMortgage Origination Volumes
TickerCompanySegmentTrend · 13mo30D1Y
FICOFair IsaacData, Analytics & Intelligence🔴 Cont. Bear−22.7%−43.1%
ALKTAlkami TechnologyCommerce & Digital Payments🌱 Emerging Bull−29.2%−43.9%
QTWOQ2Commerce & Digital Payments🌱 Emerging Bull−12.4%−24.8%
NCNOnCinoCommerce & Digital Payments🌱 Emerging Bull−6.6%−33.0%
BLBlackLineOther🔴 Cont. Bear−11.7%−48.4%
GWREGuidewire SoftwareIndustry-Specific Platforms🌱 Emerging Bull−19.9%−36.2%
SSNCSS&C TechnologiesEnterprise Resource Planning🌱 Emerging Bull−4.4%−9.2%
TYLTyler TechnologiesIndustry-Specific Platforms🌱 Emerging Bull−5.5%−36.9%
VERXVertexCommerce & Digital Payments🔴 Cont. Bear−13.7%−53.5%

12-month price & trend

FICO
Fair Isaac
879
−0.84 (−0.10%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
FICO 12-month price
Data, Analytics & Intelligence
ALKT
Alkami Technology
14.19
−0.41 (−2.84%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
ALKT 12-month price
Commerce & Digital Payments
QTWO
Q2
55.45
−0.21 (−0.38%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
QTWO 12-month price
Commerce & Digital Payments
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
FICO$15.2B19.3x15.6x6.0x5.8x7.0x6.7x16.1x7.0%
ALKT$1.4Bn/m16.2x2.8x2.7x4.9x4.7x273.4x3.8%
QTWO$4.6B41.8x26.4x5.2x5.1x9.0x8.8x27.0x5.0%
NCNO
nCino
19.14
−0.09 (−0.46%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
NCNO 12-month price
Commerce & Digital Payments
BL
BlackLine
27.75
−0.38 (−1.33%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
BL 12-month price
Other
GWRE
Guidewire Software
151
−2.01 (−1.31%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
GWRE 12-month price
Industry-Specific Platforms
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
NCNO$2.4B73.1x17.2x3.9x3.7x6.3x6.0x28.7x5.5%
BL$1.5B38.0x10.4x2.0x2.0x2.7x2.6x18.5x11.4%
GWRE$13.3B97.8x38.8x9.0x7.8x14.1x12.1x63.9x2.2%
SSNC
SS&C Technologies
79.32
−0.40 (−0.50%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
SSNC 12-month price
Enterprise Resource Planning
TYL
Tyler Technologies
330
−2.69 (−0.81%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
TYL 12-month price
Industry-Specific Platforms
VERX
Vertex
11.58
−0.14 (−1.19%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
VERX 12-month price
Commerce & Digital Payments
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
SSNC$18.2B21.8x10.9x2.7x2.7x5.7x5.6x11.3x9.6%
TYL$16.7B52.4x32.1x6.7x6.6x14.3x13.9x29.9x4.4%
VERX$2.8Bn/m20.4x3.4x3.3x5.5x5.3x53.5x1.0%

Consensus projections

TickerFY2026EFY2027EFY2028E
FICORevenue+27.2%+3.7%+4.6%
EPS+44.6%+6.1%+8.6%
ALKTRevenue+19.9%+14.4%+14.4%
EPS+59.0%+30.1%+26.1%
QTWORevenue+12.5%+10.2%+10.0%
EPS+17.9%+23.8%+17.2%
NCNORevenue+9.8%+8.9%+8.6%
EPS+25.2%+45.3%+19.9%
BLRevenue+9.5%+10.4%+10.3%
EPS+19.7%+10.9%+18.0%
GWRERevenue+23.8%+17.2%+15.6%
EPS+41.5%+20.0%+27.5%
SSNCRevenue+8.4%+5.1%+4.9%
EPS+17.7%+8.6%+8.4%
TYLRevenue+8.7%+9.9%+9.8%
EPS+14.8%+18.9%+14.1%
VERXRevenue+10.7%+10.4%+11.3%
EPS+30.8%+22.3%+23.5%

Forward fiscal years only. Blank means no analyst coverage for that year.

Fair Isaac raised the wholesale royalty it charges for a mortgage credit score from $4.95 to $10 for 2026, a unilateral increase passed through by the credit bureaus and the resellers who assemble three-bureau reports. The money arrived exactly as designed. In the quarter ended 30 June, mortgage-origination revenue grew 97% and accounted for 62% of the Scores segment, whose revenue reached $458.9m against $324.3m a year earlier.

The trouble is what a price set by one company invites. On 3 September, Federal Housing Finance Agency director Bill Pulte directed Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to approve every eligible lender to use VantageScore 4.0, converting a pilot that began on 1 May into a market-wide choice. Fair Isaac — which sells credit scores licensed through the bureaus and decisioning software to lenders, and carries a $19.0bn market value — closed the next session down 16.7%, and has kept sliding since.

Ten dollars against one

The rival is not priced to compete at the margin. TransUnion cut VantageScore 4.0 to $0.99 for mortgage lenders and bundles it free with a FICO score purchase through 2026; Experian made it free indefinitely; Equifax has committed to $1 through the end of 2027. VantageScore says its 4.0 model had already taken more than 9% of mortgage securitizations backed by the two government-sponsored enterprises by the end of August — before the directive.

Chief executive Will Lansing did not dispute the setup on the July 29 call. "It is a reality that Vantage is selling scores and is sending them along with FICO Scores... gaming is a reality and we're going to have gaming," he said. "The rules of the road, the environment that we're operating in is a gaming environment. The FHFA has put it in place. The GSEs have accepted it. And so that's the world we have." His defense was the product: "10T is absolutely the best score in the world for measuring credit default risk."

Volume will not rescue the toll. The Mortgage Bankers Association forecast about $2.2trn of single-family originations in 2026, roughly 8% above 2025, and has since trimmed that to about $2.12trn. Essentially all of the 97% is price.

Meanwhile the reported numbers are the best in years: revenue up 25.7%, operating margin of 53.8% against 48.9%, and guidance raised to $2.53bn for the fiscal year. Diluted shares fell 7.6% year on year, so earnings per share grew 41% on net income growth of 30.5% — about ten points of the EPS gain bought rather than earned, helped by a $1.5bn term loan drawn in June to fund an accelerated repurchase. The shares are down 42.7% over twelve months and trade at 25.3x trailing and 20.5x forward earnings, against roughly 44x forward at the twelve-month high close. Consensus already has fiscal 2027 revenue growth halving to 14%.

Paid by the seat instead

The contrast is not with every software vendor that rallied this summer — the rebound off the June low swept in public-sector and insurance-systems companies with no bank exposure at all. It is with the two firms billed per registered digital user. Q2 Holdings, which sells digital-banking software to regional and community banks and credit unions, reported subscription annual recurring revenue of $826m, up 15%, and $2.76bn of remaining performance obligations. Revenue growth decelerated to 12.6%, but gross margin expanded to 59.2% from 53.6% and operating income nearly tripled. It trades at 19.2x forward earnings against 37.6x trailing — the market paying for the margin ramp.

Alkami, its smaller Plano, Texas rival, showed annual recurring revenue of $511.7m, up 21%, on 23.6m registered users, up 13%. Then on 23 September its board concluded a review of strategic opportunities and chose to stay independent, reaffirming revenue guidance of $528m–$531m and adjusted EBITDA of $96m–$98m word for word. The shares fell 19.3% to $14.60 — below the $18.17 they closed at on 31 July, before advisers began approaching buyers. More than a deal premium came out.

nCino, which sells loan-origination and onboarding software to the same institutions, shows what the seat model avoids: its US mortgage subscription revenue fell 1% to $20.6m last quarter while everything else accelerated to 12%, and management blamed higher-for-longer rates driving churn among independent mortgage banks.

What the de-rating is actually pricing

None of Fair Isaac's meters has turned. The de-rating is a forecast, and a specific one: that a royalty set unilaterally is worth less when a regulator hands every lender a substitute at a tenth of the price. Seat-based vendors face pressure of a different kind — Q2's growth is slowing, Alkami's has halved from 28.9% to 15.9%, and per-institution pricing limits how far account-level expansion carries either — but no memo from Washington can replace a bank's core software in a quarter.

Equifax's dollar price runs through the end of 2027. Fair Isaac's fiscal-year guidance, due with fourth-quarter results, is the first place management has to say what it thinks that costs.