DK Street Journal

Maximus Is Paid by the Case, and 21 Million Medicaid Redeterminations Start in January

Hypothesis Opus 5 · Research Opus 5 · Writing Opus 5 · Prompt v1.6

One industry heading holds a company whose earnings multiple has halved and another that has more than doubled on data-center construction, and the label explains neither.

Maximus, which administers government health programs, has reported falling revenue for three straight quarters and cut fiscal 2026 adjusted earnings guidance to $7.90–8.20 after the Department of Veterans Affairs paused performance incentives worth roughly $0.35 a quarter. Consensus earnings per share still rise this year, yet the shares change hands near 8.3 times trailing earnings against roughly 16.4 times a year ago.

The de-rating is not idiosyncratic — Booz Allen and Leidos fell with it while defense-weighted CACI and SAIC rose. What the multiple prices is permanence, and a Medicaid caseload fixed in law arrives on 1 January.

MMSTHFABAHLDOSICFICACISAICRHIKFYADPPAYXSPYGovernment Services OutsourcingFederal Civilian BudgetsDefense & Intelligence ContractingContract Recompete RiskVeterans Health Programs
TickerCompanySegmentTrend · 13mo30D1Y
The subject · what this brief is about
MMSMaximusProfessional Information & Advisory🔴 Cont. Bear+3.3%−35.6%
THTarget HospitalityFood & Hospitality🟢 Cont. Bull+16.0%+118.0%
FAFirst AdvantageProfessional Information & Advisory🟢 Cont. Bull−2.7%+34.5%
Compared against · context, not the story
BAHBooz Allen HamiltonGovernment & Policy Advisory🔴 Cont. Bear−2.7%−26.4%
LDOSLeidosDefense & Government Services🔴 Cont. Bear−9.1%−29.4%
ICFIICF InternationalGovernment & Policy Advisory🌱 Emerging Bull−2.0%−13.1%
CACICACI InternationalDefense & Government Services⚠️ Emerging Bear−8.0%+25.2%
SAICScience Applications InternationalDefense & Government Services🟢 Cont. Bull+3.4%+23.4%
RHIRobert HalfSpecialized Professional Staffing🟢 Cont. Bull−9.8%+11.5%
KFYKorn FerryExecutive Search & Consulting🟢 Cont. Bull−6.9%+9.8%
ADPAutomatic Data ProcessingEnterprise Resource Planning🌱 Emerging Bull−0.8%−7.2%
PAYXPaychexPayroll & HCM Platforms🌱 Emerging Bull−4.9%−11.4%
SPYState Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF TrustAsset Management🟢 Cont. Bull−1.6%+17.2%

12-month price & trend

MMS
Maximus
56.92
+0.18 (+0.32%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
MMS 12-month price
Professional Information & Advisory
TH
Target Hospitality
19.25
+0.17 (+0.86%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
TH 12-month price
Food & Hospitality
FA
First Advantage
21.22
+0.57 (+2.76%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
FA 12-month price
Professional Information & Advisory
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
MMS$2.9B8.2x7.0x0.6x0.6x2.3x2.3x6.3x14.7%
TH$2.1Bn/m—6.1x4.8x83.0x65.6x66.8x4.2%
FA$3.6B140.6x16.3x2.1x2.1x5.9x5.7x12.5x6.8%
BAH
Booz Allen Hamilton
75.90
+0.40 (+0.53%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
BAH 12-month price
Government & Policy Advisory
LDOS
Leidos
129
−1.27 (−0.98%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
LDOS 12-month price
Defense & Government Services
ICFI
ICF International
85.95
−0.84 (−0.96%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
ICFI 12-month price
Government & Policy Advisory
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
BAH$9.5B12.3x12.3x0.9x0.8x1.9x1.9x10.4x11.8%
LDOS$14.8B10.9x9.5x0.8x0.8x4.8x4.6x9.0x14.6%
ICFI$1.6B17.8x12.2x0.9x0.8x2.4x2.3x11.2x12.8%
CACI
CACI International
621
−7.11 (−1.13%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
CACI 12-month price
Defense & Government Services
SAIC
Science Applications International
130
+0.68 (+0.53%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
SAIC 12-month price
Defense & Government Services
RHI
Robert Half
37.68
+0.26 (+0.69%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
RHI 12-month price
Specialized Professional Staffing
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
CACI$13.6B25.3x18.7x1.4x1.3x6.6x5.8x17.1x9.4%
SAIC$5.4B14.7x11.9x0.7x0.7x5.7x5.8x7.8x11.5%
RHI$4.0B34.1x30.9x0.8x0.8x2.1x2.1x26.3x5.4%
KFY
Korn Ferry
77.59
−0.28 (−0.36%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
KFY 12-month price
Executive Search & Consulting
ADP
Automatic Data Processing
268
+0.35 (+0.13%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
ADP 12-month price
Enterprise Resource Planning
PAYX
Paychex
116
+0.50 (+0.43%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
PAYX 12-month price
Payroll & HCM Platforms
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
KFY$3.9B13.1x12.4x1.3x1.1x13.1x11.2x7.1x8.2%
ADP$119.8B26.8x24.5x5.4x5.1x10.7x10.3x18.4x4.2%
PAYX$45.2B25.9x21.3x6.9x6.6x9.3x8.9x16.1x5.1%
SPY
State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust
764
+6.45 (+0.85%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
SPY 12-month price
Asset Management
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
SPY$773.0B————————

Consensus projections

TickerFY2026EFY2027EFY2028E
MMSRevenue−4.2%+2.9%+8.5%
EPS+7.5%+4.4%+12.3%
THRevenue+38.7%+68.9%+12.2%
EPS−89.1%−2666.7%+32.7%
FARevenue+10.3%+6.6%+8.2%
EPS+26.9%+18.0%+17.0%
BAHRevenue−6.1%+0.7%+4.2%
EPS−4.3%+5.1%+5.1%
LDOSRevenue+5.2%+6.1%+4.7%
EPS+17.1%+4.6%+2.9%
ICFIRevenue+1.8%+5.9%+8.3%
EPS+5.1%+8.5%+6.4%
CACIRevenue+10.9%+12.7%+6.7%
EPS+14.2%+16.7%+15.4%
SAICRevenue−2.4%+0.0%+1.1%
EPS+15.3%+6.0%+5.8%
RHIRevenue−1.0%+4.1%+5.2%
EPS−4.5%+55.5%+26.1%
KFYRevenue+6.8%+21.1%+10.9%
EPS+9.7%+7.1%+11.8%
ADPRevenue+7.0%+6.2%+5.7%
EPS+11.0%+11.6%+9.4%
PAYXRevenue+16.5%+5.5%+5.5%
EPS+10.1%+8.6%+7.5%

Forward fiscal years only. Blank means no analyst coverage for that year.

Maximus runs the eligibility files and phone lines behind American public health programs — Medicaid and Affordable Care Act marketplace enrollment, multilingual contact centers for government health and human-services agencies, independent medical reviews and appeals — and it has now reported three consecutive quarters of shrinking revenue. Analysts still expect its earnings per share to rise this year.

The shares have lost more than a third of their value over twelve months, and profits did almost none of that work. A year ago the company was worth about 16.4 times the earnings it went on to report for fiscal 2025; it now trades near 8.3 times trailing earnings, with free cash flow equal to roughly 14.5% of its market value. Underneath the halved multiple is a federal civilian services market that stopped buying on schedule — and a company whose largest earner is rebid every year.

The hole in this year's earnings

The Department of Veterans Affairs paused performance incentives and disincentives on its Medical Disability Exam program effective 1 July 2026, expected to run through the end of December. Those incentives had contributed about $0.35 of earnings per share in each of the first three quarters of fiscal 2026. Maximus cut adjusted earnings guidance to $7.90–8.20 from $8.25–8.55 and left revenue guidance of $5.2–5.35bn untouched — an earnings event rather than a demand one.

"These incentives have become a bigger contribution for us in our fiscal year '26 than they have been in prior years, which is really a testament to the investments we've made into the program over the past several years that have brought us to the high level of performance across the incentive metrics," chief financial officer David Mutryn told investors on August 6.

That program is also the recompete. Maximus holds one of four positions on the follow-on veterans exam contract vehicle, with a $13.2bn ceiling, alongside Leidos subsidiary QTC Medical Services, Optumserve Health Services and Loyal Source Government Services. The regional awards carry a one-year base with a single option year, so the risk recurs annually rather than on a comfortable multi-year cycle. Chief executive Bruce Caswell said preliminary analysis of the draft performance work statement indicates it covers all six regions the company serves today.

A budget-line split, not a company one

Maximus was not singled out. Over the same twelve months Booz Allen Hamilton fell 27.8%, Leidos 31.5% and ICF International 13.6%, while defense- and intelligence-weighted CACI rose 24.3% and SAIC 20.1%. The line runs through the appropriation, not through execution quality, and Maximus is trying to cross it: it has identified a $47bn addressable market in defense and national security, with wins at the Air Force and the Transportation Security Administration.

The bear's evidence is conversion. The pipeline is $50.4bn, more than half of it federal, but year-to-date signed awards were $1.25bn — a book-to-bill near half — with another $1.35bn awarded and unsigned as long recompetes cleared protest. Management described civilian-agency opportunities delayed, rescoped or canceled, with more bridge contracts and short extensions.

What comes next is dated. The 2025 reconciliation law requires 44 states and the District of Columbia to condition Medicaid eligibility for the expansion population on work requirements from 1 January 2027, with 34 of them verifying compliance every six months at renewal. That is 21 million beneficiaries to be redetermined semiannually — the caseload Maximus is paid per case to process. A federal court rejected the challenge to the requirements on 29 July, and the company expects its U.S. Services segment back to mid-single-digit organic growth in the September quarter.

The label's other tenants

Two companies share Maximus's industry heading and share nothing else with it. Target Hospitality owns 27 temporary-accommodation communities holding roughly 15,500 beds, and has more than doubled over the year on work unrelated to any appropriation: since January it has signed over 9,000 contracted beds representing more than $1.4bn of multiyear contracts for AI data-center construction crews, including a 48-month agreement expected to exceed $750m. Its government segment — the part the shared label implies is the engine — shrank to $13m in the June quarter, with $5–7m of transitional costs booked to redeploy those assets. The business is still loss-making, at an operating margin of -8.8% in the quarter and 60.4 times trailing enterprise value to EBITDA, which is a price for 2027, when consensus has revenue at $731m.

First Advantage, which screens job applicants and bills per screen, is the read on hiring, and it is soft. Base revenue grew 6.7% in the June quarter; management attributed about half of that to episodic enterprise-wide rescreening and labor restructuring, implying underlying volume growth near 3%, and guided the fourth quarter to a neutral base contribution. It raised full-year revenue guidance to $1.67–1.71bn on pricing, attach rates and Sterling synergies, and at 16.5 times forward earnings against 26.9% expected earnings growth this year, the price is not the stretch here. US payrolls rose 162,000 in August with unemployment at 4.1%; nothing in the screening book contradicts that.

The verdict

Four percent less revenue and a $0.35 incentive hole earn a lower price for Maximus. They do not obviously earn a multiple half what it was, on a company consensus still has growing earnings every year through fiscal 2028. The market is pricing permanence — that civilian agencies keep buying less, that recompetes keep landing as bridges, and that the veterans exam work is lost rather than repriced. The January redeterminations are the first thing on the calendar capable of testing that, and they are a policy, not a forecast. Federal funding itself runs to 11 December 2026 under the latest extension.

The rebid is decided a year at a time; the caseload arrives on a date already written into law. The current price assumes neither goes Maximus's way.

Sources (63)

Also checked against 39 company-fundamentals reads, 13 price-database queries in the author's own data.

Originating hypothesis

segment emerging bull appropriation funded contracts vs hiring volume · subject: MMS, TH, FA

The quietest turning bullish in this loop's sampled universe is a corner of industrials this front page has never touched once: "Industrials > Specialty Business Services > Government & Workforce Services" (MMS, TH, FA) is tagged turning bullish with prices grinding UP 7.3% over thirty days against +36.5% over twelve months, and not one of the three appears in any 1m/3m/6m/12m mover list — so both the year and the turn the bands are now marking are grinds rather than gaps, which makes this still actionable rather than a post-mortem. Rather than another price-versus-fundamentals divergence, the story worth telling is where the money actually comes from, because two of these companies are not paid by a market at all but by a congressional appropriation, and the third is paid by the private labour market — the identical heading hiding opposite drivers. Maximus does not sell "services" in any way its revenue line makes legible: it is a government business-process outsourcer whose top line is a portfolio of multi-year federal, state and foreign contracts — CMS contact-centre work, Medicaid and marketplace eligibility determination, and federal student-loan servicing — priced variously per case, per call-minute, per enrollee or cost-plus-fee, so the honest meters are signed awards and total contract value, backlog and its coverage of forward revenue, recompete outcomes on the handful of contracts that carry outsized revenue, and segment operating margin by contract type, not demand for anything; its revenue rises when a policy creates caseload (redeterminations, repayment restart) and falls on a single lost recompete regardless of how well it performs. Target Hospitality is the mirror and the reason the label conflates: not a services firm but an owner of modular workforce and government housing communities whose government segment is substantially a minimum-revenue commitment — the customer pays for beds whether or not they are occupied — so its earnings are a claim on one or two federal contracts' term, renewal option and funded-capacity terms, bolted to a genuinely cyclical Permian workforce-lodging book priced per man-day that has nothing to do with government at all. First Advantage, filed under the same heading, is a background-screening vendor billed per screen and is therefore a direct derivative of US hiring volume — the control that shows whether this group's advance is a labour-market signal or an appropriations one.