DK Street Journal

Celestica and Sanmina Beat and Raised. Their Multiples Fell While Dell's Doubled.

Hypothesis Opus 5 · Research Opus 5 · Writing Opus 5 · Prompt v1.4

Almost every company that builds the physical machinery of an AI data center reported in the past six weeks, and almost all of them raised guidance. Investors then repriced them in opposite directions, and the split runs along business model rather than results.

The branded server and storage makers got more expensive on shrinking or flat margins. What buyers pay for each dollar of Dell's trailing gross profit has gone from 6.99x in May to 12.77x, even though its gross margin fell 337 basis points last quarter. NetApp's has nearly doubled too. The contract manufacturers went the other way while their profitability improved: Celestica raised full-year revenue guidance to $20.5bn and de-rated 19%; Sanmina expanded gross margin 160 basis points and de-rated 15%.

The outlier is Supermicro, which disclosed $60bn of orders in one quarter and trades at 12.3x forward earnings.

DELLSMCINTAPCLSJBLFLEXSANMPENGHPE
TickerCompanySegmentTrend · 13mo30D1Y
The subject · what this brief is about
DELLDell TechnologiesEnterprise Storage & Software🟢 Cont. Bull+28.5%+259.3%
SMCISuper Micro ComputerServer & Infrastructure Systems🔴 Cont. Bear+67.2%−13.1%
NTAPNetAppEnterprise Storage & Software🟢 Cont. Bull+28.5%+92.9%
CLSCelesticaElectronic Manufacturing Services🟢 Cont. Bull+9.0%+71.9%
JBLJabilElectronic Manufacturing Services🟢 Cont. Bull+18.7%+68.5%
FLEXFlexElectronic Manufacturing Services🟢 Cont. Bull+5.2%+153.5%
SANMSanminaElectronic Manufacturing Services🟢 Cont. Bull+4.4%+79.6%
PENGPenguin SolutionsData Infrastructure & Software Solutions🌱 Emerging Bull+19.9%+158.1%
Compared against · context, not the story
HPEHewlett Packard EnterpriseEnterprise Storage & Software🟢 Cont. Bull+31.8%+176.3%

12-month price & trend

DELL
Dell Technologies
491
−3.70 (−0.75%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
DELL 12-month price
Enterprise Storage & Software
SMCI
Super Micro Computer
39.84
+0.68 (+1.74%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
SMCI 12-month price
Server & Infrastructure Systems
NTAP
NetApp
207
+2.54 (+1.24%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
NTAP 12-month price
Enterprise Storage & Software
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
DELL$326.2B38.4x26.6x2.4x1.9x12.8x10.0x23.4x2.9%
SMCI$25.8B10.9x12.3x0.7x0.5x6.1x4.5x8.2x-27.1%
NTAP$40.6B32.2x23.2x5.9x5.4x8.3x7.7x21.1x4.6%
CLS
Celestica
335
−26.29 (−7.28%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
CLS 12-month price
Electronic Manufacturing Services
JBL
Jabil
363
−11.70 (−3.12%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
JBL 12-month price
Electronic Manufacturing Services
FLEX
Flex
126
−0.48 (−0.38%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
FLEX 12-month price
Electronic Manufacturing Services
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
CLS$38.5B34.5x29.5x2.5x1.9x21.3x16.2x25.7x1.3%
JBL$38.0B44.8x28.5x1.1x1.1x12.3x11.8x19.1x4.0%
FLEX$46.6B48.7x26.9x1.6x1.3x16.8x14.2x26.1x2.3%
SANM
Sanmina
211
+0.23 (+0.11%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
SANM 12-month price
Electronic Manufacturing Services
PENG
Penguin Solutions
63.80
+1.05 (+1.67%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
PENG 12-month price
Data Infrastructure & Software Solutions
HPE
Hewlett Packard Enterprise
58.71
−1.11 (−1.86%)
vs. prior close
Price20d50d150d
HPE 12-month price
Enterprise Storage & Software
TickerMkt capP/EP/E fwdP/SP/S fwdP/GPP/GP fwdEV/EBITDAFCF yld
SANM$11.3B37.0x17.4x0.9x0.8x9.8x8.9x17.8x5.3%
PENG$3.3B43.5x24.4x2.2x2.0x7.8x7.0x20.3x-2.0%
HPE$79.2B54.9x17.5x2.0x1.8x6.2x5.4x23.7x5.0%

Consensus projections

TickerFY2026EFY2027EFY2028E
DELLRevenue+16.2%+53.6%+14.2%
EPS+27.3%+85.4%+21.0%
SMCIRevenue+77.7%+34.0%+19.7%
EPS+33.5%+15.5%+13.7%
NTAPRevenue+4.3%+9.2%+5.5%
EPS+10.4%+11.6%+10.5%
CLSRevenue+67.0%+69.3%+32.3%
EPS+90.2%+74.7%+34.3%
JBLRevenue+20.2%+21.2%+12.1%
EPS+35.9%+31.0%+20.3%
FLEXRevenue+6.8%+26.3%+30.0%
EPS+24.2%+44.7%+51.5%
SANMRevenue+74.9%+15.8%+11.8%
EPS+103.4%+15.2%+12.7%
PENGRevenue+21.2%+28.6%+14.9%
EPS+42.2%+28.3%+19.1%
HPERevenue+30.3%+11.2%+5.7%
EPS+80.1%+17.6%+9.6%

Forward fiscal years only. Blank means no analyst coverage for that year.

Almost every company that assembles the physical machinery of an artificial-intelligence data center — the racks, the boards, the storage arrays — reported results in the past six weeks. Nearly all of them raised guidance. What happened afterward sorted them not by how well they did, but by whether their name goes on the box.

The cleanest way to see it is what investors pay for each dollar of gross profit a company actually earns, measured against where that same figure sat in mid-May. On that test the brands have been marked up sharply and the contractors marked down — the reverse of what their income statements would suggest.

The brands got more expensive on worse margins

Dell Technologies, which designs and sells servers, storage and PCs directly to enterprises, governments and cloud operators, reported revenue of $43.84bn for the quarter ended 1 May, up 87.5% from a year earlier. Its gross margin fell to 17.75% from 21.12%, a 337-basis-point compression, so gross profit grew far slower than sales. Operating income nearly tripled anyway, on volume. Dell exited the quarter with a record $51.3bn AI backlog after booking $24.4bn of orders, and management lifted its full-year outlook to a $167bn revenue midpoint with $60bn of AI-server revenue.

The repricing has been faster than the profit. Dell now trades at 12.77x trailing gross profit, against 6.99x in May, and at 38.4x trailing and 26.6x forward earnings. As recently as spring it was defensible as the cheapest large-cap way to own the buildout, at 14-17x forward earnings. That argument no longer holds at this price.

NetApp, which sells ONTAP data-management software and all-flash storage arrays to enterprises, is the quiet accelerator. Revenue growth has risen for four straight quarters — 1.2%, 2.8%, 4.4%, then 12.5% in the April quarter — with gross margin held at 70.07%, the highest in the group, and operating margin widening to 27.26% from 20.09%. It reported record full-year all-flash revenue of about $4.2bn and roughly 500 AI-related wins in the quarter. Its price-to-gross-profit has gone from 4.55x to 8.29x. Consensus still models only 9.2% revenue growth this fiscal year, below what NetApp just printed.

Super Micro Computer breaks the pattern in the other direction. The maker of liquid-cooled, rack-scale AI systems grew revenue 93.2% to $11.12bn in the June quarter, with gross margin at 17.47% against 9.45% a year earlier — an 802-basis-point expansion. It guided the current quarter to $14.5-15.5bn against a $11.99bn consensus and the year to $65-72bn against $54.43bn, disclosing $60bn of new orders in a single quarter. It trades at 12.3x forward earnings and 4.49x forward gross profit — the cheapest name here on every lens. Three caveats belong with that: the margin path over the year was 9.31%, 6.30%, 9.95%, then 17.47%, so June is a break rather than a trend; trailing free cash flow is deeply negative at a −27.1% yield as inventory absorbs cash; and consensus earnings for this year, $3.24 a share, still sit below last year's $3.26, which is why its forward multiple is higher than its trailing one.

The contractors beat and got cheaper

Celestica, the Toronto company that builds switches, interconnects and full server racks for hyperscalers rather than under its own brand, grew revenue 62.4% to $4.70bn last quarter with gross margin down just 53 basis points and operating margin up. It raised full-year guidance to $20.5bn of revenue and $11.30 of adjusted earnings per share, and disclosed two 2027 programs with multi-billion-dollar potential: custom racks for OpenAI's accelerator with Broadcom, and a build role on AMD's Helios interconnect. It has still de-rated from 26.26x trailing gross profit in May to 21.29x. The proximate cause is a corporate action, not a stumble: a $3bn stock sale to fund the buildout, priced 5 August at $310, was followed by a 14.8% drop the next session.

Sanmina, which makes circuit boards, backplanes and enclosures for other people's designs, grew revenue 69.7% to $3.46bn with gross margin expanding 160 basis points to 10.49%. Cloud and AI infrastructure is now 62% of its revenue, up 173%. Management guided full-year earnings to roughly double, and the shares slipped anyway as investors weighed the working capital the ramp consumes. It carries the lowest forward multiple of any contractor at 17.4x and the highest free-cash-flow yield in the group at 5.3%.

Flex, a manufacturing and supply-chain provider whose lines include data-center switchgear and power distribution, grew revenue 20.6% with gross margin up 72 basis points, and says roughly 90% of the next three quarters is already booked. Its price-to-gross-profit has fallen from 21.42x to 16.79x.

Jabil is the honest exception on both sides: revenue growth decelerated from 23.1% to 11.8%, and its multiple barely moved. Penguin Solutions, the smallest member at $3.3bn and the only one down over the past month, is the pure memory-inflation case — its Integrated Memory revenue rose 111% on volume and pricing while non-GAAP gross margin fell 3.6 points. Its chief financial officer left on 8 July.

What the month's gain is made of

An equal-weighted basket of the eight is up 12.0% over 30 days. Strip each name's two best sessions and that becomes −8.0%; four of the eight were flat or down before any stripping. Dell's largest single day was a 32.76% gain on 29 May, after earnings. Two months later, on 29 July, every contractor fell together — Penguin 9.2%, Flex 9.1%, Celestica 6.2% — as chip and AI-infrastructure shares lost more than $1trn on fears that capital-spending growth is merely slowing, then all rebounded the next day. Dell's 50-day average has sat above its 200-day since 31 March; Celestica's stepped down in mid-August.

The memory story is real but narrow. Server DRAM contract prices rose 90-95% in the first quarter and NAND 55-60%, and passing that through at no markup inflates revenue while crushing margin — which is exactly what Dell's and Penguin's numbers show. It is not what Celestica's, Sanmina's, Flex's or Jabil's show. Their margins went up.

The setup

Where it stands — The contract builders raised guidance and expanded margins yet trade at lower multiples of gross profit than in May; the brands did the reverse. Would confirm — Celestica delivering third-quarter revenue inside its $5.25-5.55bn guide with gross margin still in the mid-11s. Would invalidate — Contractor gross margins contracting next quarter, or a cut to Sanmina's $11.90-12.20 full-year earnings guide. Watch next — Supermicro's next quarterly report against its own $14.5-15.5bn revenue guide and consensus earnings that still sit below last year. Valuation — Supermicro 10.9x trailing and 12.3x forward earnings; Sanmina 37.0x and 17.4x; Dell 38.4x and 26.6x, against 28.3x trailing in May.